LATEST: Go to for the latest Article II eligibility news ...
Friday, August 6, 2010

2007: MSNBC's Chris "Old School Birther" Matthews Reported Obama 
Was Born In Indonesia And Has Islamic Background;  Got Hypocrite!?

 BIRTHER REPORT EXCLUSIVE; Well, well, well it appears the Democratic insider Chris Matthews over at MSNBC is a Birther, at least he was in 2007.  In mid December of 2007, on his low rated leftist propaganda show, 'Hardball with Chris Matthews,' Matthews was discussing the heated campaign between Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama AKA Barry Soetoro AKA Soebarkah when he stated the unthinkable.  The comment was regarding former Democrat Senator Bob Kerrey whom was defending Obama from the suggested smear campaign.  During the exchange Matthews very clearly stated, which has been captured by screenshot below, and can also be viewed at the MSNBC website(about 3/4 of the way down, see it before they scrub it (2011 still there!), stated the following;

"But didn‘t Hillary dump on Obama a few days ago for playing up his Indonesian roots? So, what is she up to here? Is she pushing how great he is for having been born in Indonesia, or what, or simply reminding everybody about his background, his Islamic background?"
- Chris Matthews - 12/18/2007 -

Now before all the Obots say it is being taken out of context, and to be fair to Matthews, I will post the researched segment of the transcript, in full, below the screenshot, including more commentary. We wouldn't want it to be taken out of context;
continued below transcript


MATTHEWS: Welcome back to HARDBALL.

So, what else is new out there? Well, let‘s—let‘s all listen to former Senator Bob Kerrey, Clinton supporter, talk up rival Barack Obama.


BOB KERREY (D), FORMER U.S. SENATOR: There is a smear campaign going on. And people acting as if he‘s an Islamic “Manchurian Candidate.” And I feel it‘s actually a substantial strength.

He is a Christian. Both he and his family are Christians. They have chosen Christianity. But that connection to Indonesia and a billion Muslims on this Earth, I think, is a real strength, and add an awful—a lot of value in his foreign policy efforts.

I have told Barack Obama, when I have met with him—it‘s something that I have spoken about before, so this is not something that just sort of came out of the head-birth out there in Iowa. I thought about it a great deal. I have—I have watched the blogs try to say that—that you can‘t trust him because he spent a little bit of time in a secular madrassa.


MATTHEWS: So, is Hillary backer Bob Kerrey pretending to sell Obama, but clearly putting the shiv in?

Here is Hillary Clinton defending him and Bob Kerrey: “I think the remarks were very positive. I know Bob. He was being very complimentary of Senator Obama. He was making a point that Senator Obama makes himself all the time, that, because of his upbringing and his heritage, he is, in his view”—“in his view”—catch that line—“very well-suited to communicate with the rest of the world. And he has just himself that he wants to have a particular outreach to the Islamic world. So, I think Senator Kerrey was being, you know, very generous in what he said.”

But didn‘t Hillary dump on Obama a few days ago for playing up his Indonesian roots? So, what is she up to here? Is she pushing how great he is for having been born in Indonesia, or what, or simply reminding everybody about his background, his Islamic background?

Remember a couple weeks ago, when White House spokeswoman Dana Perino, who speaks for the president of the United States, giddily explained that she didn‘t know anything about the Cuban Missile Crisis.

Well, today, our Cuban expert at the White House reacted to Fidel Castro‘s suggestion that he might leave office—quote—“We‘re just continuing to work for democracy on the island, and we believe that that day will come soon.”

So, Dana Perino doesn‘t know the past, but she knows the future?

And, finally, it‘s time for the HARDBALL “Big Number” tonight.

Bill Clinton‘s latest angle to help Hillary sounds a bit obtuse. CNN reports that Monday, in South Carolina, Bill said that—quote—“The first thing Hillary Clinton plans to do as president of the United States is to send him, Bill, and former President George Herbert Walker Bush around the world to tell them that America‘s open for business and cooperation again.”

Really? Does Bill think putting his arm around one Bush will help Hillary follow the other one in office? Does it really make her the change candidate to join forces with the father of the guy who needs changing, as she sees it? Doesn‘t this spotlight the Bush-Clinton/Bush-Clinton dynasty scenario that makes some people a little antsy?

As Bill says, your answer depends on what you think the question is.

Either way, we know what the HARDBALL “Big Number” is tonight: 41, as in Bush 41, who, according to Bill Clinton, would be a major player in Hillary Clinton‘s foreign policy lineup.

Up next, we will get the story from Iowa, where Bill Clinton campaigned with Hillary today.

You‘re watching HARDBALL on the campaign trail in Hanover, New Hampshire, only on MSNBC.

(COMMERCIAL BREAK) End Research - Full Transcript;

Does this mean Chris Matthews was a Birther before he was not a Birther!? Does this mean that Usurper Obama is NOT a "natural born Citizen" as required by Article II Section 1 Clause 5 of the United States Constitution!? The evidence is very clear!

"No person except a natural born citizen, or a citizen of the United States, at the time of the adoption of this Constitution, shall be eligible to the office of President; neither shall any person be eligible to that office who shall not have attained to the age of thirty five years, and been fourteen Years a resident within the United States."

Matthews, now that we know you're a Birther can you please retract the comments you made the other night when you stated that "Birthers are the most un-American of people" and that Birthers are trying to "Assassinate" Obama "With Their Lies"... Please!?
[Video of Matthews recent Birther attack here] Usurper Obama, can you please release ALL the records you fight to keep sealed!?

I wonder if Matthews likes to hang out with Poppa Birther Jonathan Turley, the Father of Modern Birtherdom(FOMB)!?

NOTE: Chris Matthews is creating a straw man argument when he states that Birthers believe that the Obama family planned all this back in 1961 because they knew he was going to run for President some day. No Chris, you are saying that as a stupid straw man argument that you conveniently stand up, then ridicule it, and knock it down. Birthers are not saying that Chris, you are. Birthers are saying that Grandma Dunham could have falsified the birth registration in Hawaii back then to simply get her foreign born new born grandson U.S. Citizenship. People lie today and falsify documents to get U.S. Citizenship if they can and they did it back in 1961 too. All the Birthers want to see in Hawaii is the original full and complete birth registration documents from 1961 and all subsequent amendments of Obama's birth registration records.

Citizen v natural born Citizen-It's Don't Ask Don't Tell-20100301 Issue Wash Times Natl Wkly - pg 5


  1. That is way too funny! Talk about foot in mouth. What a big putz he is.

  2. Via Email;

    MSNBC's Chris Matthews was an original Birther commenting on Obama's birth location statements, cleverly dropping questions about it and that Obama was "born in Indonesia" in an interview about the Hillary Clinton and Obama's tit for tats and the DNC nomination battle and tug of war, in December 2007. Looks like an effort on his part to plant with his viewers a Hillary Clinton opposition research seed on Obama in the public arena to help Hillary's attack machine. Now the winds have changed and it is Obama who sends a tingle up his leg. Now he viciously personally attacks any one who even mentions the topic and questions the fact that Obama has not conclusively proved to any controlling legal authority with expertise and power to obtain and validate all the original long form hidden documents to prove or disprove conclusively Obama's nativity story and early life up until and including his time at Occidental College and Columbia University. My how the worm turns as the political winds shift for a person with no common core values when it comes to intellectual honesty! But can we expect any less from a person whose hero is Saul Alinsky, a communist sympathizing radical community organizer and agitator from Chicago, who taught his disciples to lie and deceive the middle class in his book Rules for Radicals and that the ends justifies the means and anything goes as long as you win type tactics to overthrow the Constitutional Republic form of government by boring from within to destroy our economic and other systems to eventually cause it to collapse in crisis and then install a National Socialist statist form of government. Alinsky taught the old Students for a Democratic Society (SDS) network of Bill Ayers, etc., and the new, new far left that you cannot win in the streets with violence but you could win without a fight if you bore into the various systems (government, academic, education, media) over time and destroy it from within. He taught to use democracy to destroy itself. Alinsky's disciples have learned their lesson well. Obama is completely their multi-decade plan to fundamentally change America as we watch by his actions and his inactions. America and its electorate must awaken to what is going on and stand up and stop this before it is too late. The unconstitutional Usurper in Chief Obama must be removed from the Oval Office and his fellow traveler Czars with him.

    CDR Charles Kerchner (Ret)
    Pennsylvania USA
    Lead Plaintiff
    Kerchner v Obama & Congress

  3. Very nicely put CDR.

    Will any person in the media mention this bombshell?

  4. What about this article in rsol:

    From an article by Mr. Hoover in HonoluluAdvertiser dated JANUARY 8TH, 2006!!!!!


    Both were born outside the country — Obama in Indonesia, Duckworth in Thailand — and graduated from high school in Honolulu — Punahou and McKinley, respectively."

    Here is Mr. Hoover's explanation of why he got the birthplace wrong:

    "Phil… The story in question was written on deadline more nearly four years ago. The story was not about Obama, but Tammy Duckworth. I knew little about Obama at the time, other than that he had lived in Honolulu and graduated from High School here. With time running out, I Googled “Obama (and) birthplace,” (or something similar) – and incredibly THE FIRST THING (emphasis mine) I found said Obama was BORN IN INDONESIA(emphasis mine)! Hey, it looked factual (apparently it was from a site trying to discredit Obama’s Hawaiii origins – so much for trusting Google). Anyhow, that’s what wound up in the story. I quickly, and sheepishly, learned otherwise after the story appeared. I believe a correction soon followed."

    Great analysis by Phil and must read article.

  5. "'Birthers' fade after passage of law against them"


  6. LMAO That is priceless!

  7. Joseph Farah from World Net Daily just published a piece on Matthews statement, and of course as an "exclusive."

    Guess where Chris Matthews thinks 'O' was born ...

    Exclusive: Joseph Farah reveals host's claim about birthplace of president

    It should read 'Birther Report reveals host's claim about birthplace of president.'

  8. LOL Where is the video of this? This should be ran in a loop.

  9. Actually, I found it on Drudge first this AM, which is almost like Mainstream Media (everyone in Washington DC reads Drudge! Follow the links on Drudge and make sure to read all of the comments on RealClearPolitics, most all of them are with "us" on this -- Obamao the Usurper!! Get rid of him NOW!! But wait until Boehner is the Speaker of the House!! Must have been on RCP first! PEOPLE ARE WAKING UP!!

  10. The Kenyan born fraud who occupies "our" White House used a fake certificate of birth, in Hawaii, to show he met the birth requirement.
    His birth records, showing he was born in Kenya, are available to view on this website:
    Please access this site and see proof he does not qualify to be President. He should be impeached ASAP put on trial for crimes & misdemeanors.

  11. Hello Consent to all of you!

  12. There is a ton of evidence the Obama was born in Indonesia and that Ann Dunham is not his mother. There is the real possibility that Obama's Indonesian mother gave Barry to Ann Dunham to raise as her own child.


“As long as I am an American citizen and American blood runs in these veins I shall hold myself at liberty to speak, to write, and to publish whatever I please on any subject.” - Elijah Parish Lovejoy(1802-1837)

Comments posted here do not necessarily reflect the views of Readers are solely responsible for the content of the comments they post on this web site.