LATEST: Go to for the latest Article II eligibility news ...
Thursday, March 24, 2011

~Michael Astrue - Commissioner of the Social Security Administration~

As reported here and here, attorney Orly Taitz filed a Freedom of Information violation suit regarding Obama's questionable social security number reserved for Connecticut applicants and the continued stonewalling by the Social Security Administration on numerous FOIA requests. Attorney Taitz just filed her First Amended Complaint in the case. Attorney Taitz reports that she has obtained new documents that prove Obama lied about his days at Columbia University. Full complaint with exhibits embedded below...

Via Attorney Taitz: First Amended Complaint submitted today in DC. Newly uncovered documents show that Obama was defrauding the nation re his Columbia university records, he was there only 9 months, more evidence of Social Security fraud by Obama



Current complaint filed under federal statute 5USC § 552 (a) (4)(B) and the respondents are officers of the U.S. government


Plaintiff herein is Dr. Orly Taitz, ESQ, President of “Defend Our Freedoms foundation”, filing pro se


Michael Astrue, in his official capacity as the Commissioner of the Social Security Administration

Plaintiff brings this action pursuant to the provisions of 5 USC §552 known as the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) and in particular 5 USC§552 (a)(4)(B)


1. Plaintiff, Dr. Orly Taitz, ESQ is the president of the “Defend Our Freedoms” foundation (hereinafter foundation) and an attorney, who represented this foundation.

2. Both the Plaintiff and the foundation are dedicated to the preservation of the Constitutional rights and freedoms of the U.S. citizens.

3. Plaintiff works closely with a number of licensed investigators.

3. Intervener received a report and an affidavit from a licensed investigator and former elite Anti Communist Proliferation and Anti Organized Crime unit of the Scotland Yard officer Neil Sankey. Mr. Sankey’s report showed that Barack Hussein Obama (hereinafter “Obama”) is linked in the national databases to some 39 different Social Security numbers and multiple addresses. None of these numbers was issued in the state of Hawaii. The number that he used most often since around 1980 and still uses today, while residing in the White House, is a Connecticut Social Security number 042-68-4425. According to Lexis Nexis and Choice Point this number was originally issued to an elderly individual born in 1890, who resided in Connecticut, but this number was later assumed by Obama and used by him from around 1980-1981.

4. The first three digits of the Social Security number signify the state. 042 signifies the state of Connecticut.

5. Obama was never a resident of Connecticut.

6. In March-April of 1977 when this number was issued to another individual in Connecticut, Obama was a 16 year old student, residing with his grandparents in Hawaii.

7. To confirm such findings Taitz obtained an opinion of yet another licensed investigator, Susan Daniels, who attested to the fact that the national databases show multiple social security numbers associated with the name Barack Obama, among them Connecticut Social Security number 042-68-4425 used most often. She, also, found that this number was originally assigned to an individual born in 1890. Later, the same number was associated with birth dates 04.08.1961 and 08.04.1961. Dates of 04.08.1961 and 08.04.1961 suggest existence of some documents, created using an European system of dating: Day, Month, Year, versus the American system of Month, day, year. Exhibit 4

8. Obama’s selective service certificate verification, readily available on the world wide web, shows a complete match with the number 042-68-4425, therefore verification of Obama’s use of this number since 1980. Selective service match provides proof and verification via an official document issued by the U.S. government that Barack Obama is using the Social Security number 042-68-4425 Exhibit 1

9. Further use of SSNVS (Social Security Number Verification System ) shows that combination of Barack Obama’s name and the same Social Security number shows as failed, meaning that the number that Barack Obama is using, was not issued to him, but rather to another individual. This provides evidence of the Social Security Fraud and identity fraud by an individual, occupying the position of the President of the United States of America and Commander-in-chief of the US military. Exhibit 2

10 In and around 1976-1977 due to new Social Security requirements multiple elderly individuals, particularly women, who were housewives and never worked before, applied for Social Security numbers in order to obtain Social Security benefits , therefore date of birth of 1890 originally connected to 042-68-4425 was consistent with many other examples of elderly individuals, born between 1890-1915, applying for Social Security cards for the first time between 1976-1977. Exhibit 5 October 3, 2010 FOIA request and March 2, 2011 FOIA response from the Social Security Administration

11. National databases such as Lexis Nexis and Choice Point show another Social Security number, originally assigned to an elderly individual, being connected to the name Barack Obama.

12. This Social Security number 485-40-5154 is noteworthy, as it was assigned to Lucille I Ballantyne, born 12.22.1912, deceased 09.13.1998. Exhibit 4

13. Ms. Ballantyne was the mother of Harry C. Ballantyne, Chief Actuary of the Social Security Administration, who had access to all Social Security databases and death indices.

14. It is also noteworthy, that Obama’s grandmother Madeline Payne Dunham was known to volunteer at the Oahu Circuit court probate department and had access to Social Security numbers of the recently deceased individuals, whose death may or may not have been reported to the Social Security administration.

15. Taitz verified this data with the third investigator, retired Senior Deportation Officer with the Department of Homeland Security John Sampson. Exhibit 7

Mr. Sampson provided Taitz with an affidavit, stating that according to his investigation, the number Obama is using most of his life, is indeed a Connecticut Social Security number. Mr. Sampson provided an expert opinion, that there is no reasonable explanation for one residing in HI to get a CT Social Security number. He also found that on one of Obama’s entry questioners the country of origin is listed as an Equatorial Guinea, not Kenya or Hawaii.

16. At the same time Taitz found that national databases show different dates of birth for Obama: 08.01 1961, 08.04.1961 and 04.08.1961 as well as 1890.

11. Recently released passport records of Obama’s mother, Ann Dunham, show that Obama was listed in her passport under a name Soebarkah. Exhibit 6

12. AP report from Indonesia, where Obama resided, show Obama’s elementary school record under the last name Soetoro.

13. Recently Neil Abercrombie, governor of Hawaii, in an interview to Honolulu Star Advertiser admitted that he was not able to locate the original birth certificate for Obama, only a notation by someone in archives that some record exists, though no actual original certified long form U.S. birth certificate was ever found for Obama.

14. Obama provided the public only a short form certification of live birth created in 2007, right before the election, which does not contain any essential information, which typically would be found in the original long form birth certificate , such as the name of the hospital, the name of the attending physician and signatures. The state of HI statute 338-17 allows a foreign born child of Hawaiian resident to obtain a Hawaiian birth certificate.

15. The state of Hawaii statute 338-5 allows one to obtain a birth certificate based on a statement of one relative only without any corroborating evidence from any hospital.

16. The state of Hawaii statute 338-6 allows one to get a late birth certificate, obtained as a result of adoption or loss of an original birth certificate.

17. Numerous reports, claiming that prior Governor of Hawaii Linda Lingle examined Obama’s birth certificate were false as well. Lingle’s interview reveals that she relied on a statement of former Director of the Health Department Chiyome Fukino, but Lingle never personally saw a birth certificate for Obama, which means that her statement was a hearsay.

18. Director of the Health Department Chiyome Fukino made a carefully crafted statement that there is a birth record in Hawaii, but in spite of thousands of demands for clarification from the media and citizens, she refused to clarify, what record exists there. A record or notation in archives created pursuant to statute 338-5, 338-6, 338-17 would constitute “a record”, but would not be sufficient to establish Obama’s birth in Hawaii without examining corroborating evidence from the hospital, which was never produced.

19. There were reports of newspaper articles, announcing Obama’s birth in HI. Follow up research did not uncover any such article anywhere. Nobody ever produced an actual newspaper with an announcement of Obama’s birth in the U.S. Only a microfiche image was found. There is no evidence, verifying when this image was created. Even if one were to believe that such news paper announcement actually existed in 1961, when Obama was born, it still does not prove that Obama was born in HI, as news paper article is not a prima facia evidence of birth and it could have been created based on a birth certificate, created under statute 338-5, 338-6, 338-17, which do not provide proof of birth in Hawaii.

20 . Senior Deportation officer John Sampson provided Taitz with a second affidavit, stating that when there is a suspicion of illegal use of a Social Security number of another individual, Social Security Administration routinely provides redacted information regarding the original SS_5 application to the Social Security administration. Such information includes gender, race, age at application, zip code. Such information is general enough not to reveal the identity of the live holder of the social security number, but it is extremely helpful in identifying fraudulent use. Taitz repeatedly submitted FOIA requests to the SSA, but was repeatedly stonewalled and even redacted information was not provided regarding the social security number 042-68-4425. Exhibit 7, 8

21. As above information shows that Obama does not possess either a long form birth certificate or a Social Security number of his own, Taitz filed a FOIA request for the SS-5 for 042-68-4425, she agreed to accept a redacted SS-5, but it was denied.

22. In MArch of 2010 Taitz filed an appeal and obtained a final determination on May 18, 2010, when her SSA FOIA appeal was denied by Jonathan R. Canthor, Executive Director, Office of Privacy and Disclosure of the social security administration.

23. Taitz appealed to the US District Court, District of Columbia 1:2010-cv-00151, Chief Judge of the DC Court, Hon Royce Lamberth.

24. Court denied the appeal, citing that the court appeal was filed prior to the final disposition by the agency and citing privacy considerations.

25. On October 4, 2010 Taitz filed yet another FOIA request with the Social Security administration requesting redacted information. FOIA requests are supposed to be granted or denied within 20 days. Taitz sent a total of six certified mail letters with requests to either grant or deny her request, but her request was not granted or denied for six months, at which time she filed this legal action. She submitted her original complaint on February 2, 2011, it was docketed on February 16, 2011. After this complaint was filed Taitz received a response from the SSA, but no information was provided regarding SSN 042-68-4425, citing privacy. No answer to the complaint was received yet and Taitz id filing this First Amended Complaint.

26 In this First Amended Complaint Taitz provides additional information, specifically Exhibit 1 Selective Service Application for Barack Obama, showing that he uses SSN 042-68-4425 and Exhibit 2 SSNVS Social Security number Verification System, which shows that this is not a legally obtained Social Security number for Barack Obama. This is a prima facia evidence of Social Security fraud and Identity Fraud obtained from the official records of the United States Government, which coupled with the age of 121years old of the original applicant (date of birth 1890) justify release of at least redacted SS-5 information requested, such as gender, race and age of the SS5 applicant for SSN 042-68-4425 and the zip code, where the original SSN card was mailed by the social Security administration. concealment of such data will constitute aiding and abetting Social Security Fraud and Identity Theft.

27. Further records from the Student Clearing House show even more shocking evidence. In his memoirs and multiple speeches Obama wrote that he studied for two years at Columbia University September 1981-May 1983. He admitted that in summer of 1981 he traveled to Pakistan to visit his friends, but repeatedly claimed that from September 1981 until May of 1983 he resided in New York and studied at Columbia University. Taitz ran a check of his years of attendance at Columbia university and found out that Columbia official records show him attending Columbia university only for nine months September 1982-till May 1983 (Exhibit 3), which means that the President of the United States lied to the whole nation about his whereabouts for a whole year September 1981 until September 1982. One year absence is the best case scenario, as he could get his university credit by reciprocity or through extern studies.

28. As there is no record of Obama residing anywhere else in the United States from September 1981-September 1982, or attending any other university, by way of simple deduction it becomes clear that his visit to Pakistan lasted not a month or two, as he claims, but over a year.

29. In 1981-1982 Pakistan was ruled by a ruthless radical Muslim leader general Zia Ul Hac, who came to power as a result of a military coup, announced himself as a Chief Martial Law Administrator and ruled the country via the system of iron fist terror. Supreme court of Pakistan, apparently afraid for their lives found such rule to be acceptable due to a “necessity” doctrine. Based on verification of Columbia university records, Taitz found that Obama spent at least a year within the regime of general Zia Ul Hac. This revelation adds urgency in processing this complaint, as it shows that we have today an individual usurping the position of the President of the United States and Commander-in-Chief of the whole US military, while using a stolen social security number, not possessing a valid long form U.S. birth certificate and defrauding the nation and concealing a whole year of his whereabouts.

Wherefore the plaintiff respectfully prays this court:... ...Continued below including exhibits...

Previous reports on Obama's SS# can be found here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here and here. Visit the Birther Vault for the long list of evidence against Hawaii officials and all of the people questioning Obama's eligibility; [].

Taitz v. Social Security Administration - Obama's Social Security Number(s) - Freedom of information violat...




  2. This needs to be posted at Free Republic as soon as possible under these categories in lower case spelling:


    If you do that reporters, political operatives, retired intelligence officers, informants and supporters of Romney, Palin, Bachmann and others will see it and pick it up. This news is huge about attending Columbia for 9 months and dissappearing for a year in 81. Drudge should pick it up at Free Republic

  3. it was proved at the c.i.a./ columbia/ obama/ sedition and treason trial that obama never graduated from columbia university. this trial was held by dr. james manning in may 14- 19 - 2010 in new york. his degree is fraudulent. the transcripts of the trial are posted on line and have been served to all key members of congress house and senate more than once.


  5. I've always known Obama to be a liar, fraud, phony, and un-American. He should not be allowed to run for re-election. He should be impeached, jailed, or deported back to Kenya. He could probably be the next president of Libya. They need another dictator.

  6. California birther/dualer/doubterMarch 25, 2011 at 1:02 AM

    Ghadafy: Well, done, my faithful servant! Now, God willing, I may go ride off into the sunset to my retirement tent to await the day when the golden chariot will escort me to the 72 virgins anticipating my arrival.

    Obozo: Whatever, you loon. Now where's my cut of your billions? Or am I going to need to show you how things get done in Chicago? Oh, and I don't do camels, so take them and your smelly designer rags with you.

  7. Obamas 72 virgins will include Yasar Arafat, Iran's Immanutjob, and Gadafy. We all know of his homosexual tendacies in his Chicago days. Enjoy your rewards, Obama.

    Time to flush this Fraud. Go Trump! Finally mainstream attention. The lamestream thinks they will make trump look nuts, but he is waking up people that dont know the facts.

  8. drudge has not picked this up yet.

  9. You stupid people will believe anything. Orly Taitz is a moron.

  10. OK, this just creeps me out. Who the hell do we have as President? A Soviet plant? Manchurian candidate? WTH?

  11. @Anonymous

    I don't care who you are or how much you love "Obama" (or whatever his real name is), you HAVE to admit, there's something funny going on here.

    Maybe it's something as simple as an embarrassing detail about his parentage (born illegitimate, different daddy, etc.). I could get past that.

    It's possible that through no fault of his own there simply is no b/c. I have thought about that. Stranger things have happened.

    Bammie's mammy was a supremely flakey broad who strikes me as the type that would be capable of almost any kind of liberal buffoonery. Maybe she thought that a recorded long-form b/c would limit little Barry's infinite spirit or some other such idiocy.

    I lived in Hawaii for many years. Trust me, there's no limit to how off-the-charts goofy the locals (who run the palce) can be. Nothing would surprise me as far as what they would deem perfectly normal behavior in perhaps covering up Bammie's lack of or even disqualifying b/c.

  12. Don't you folks have anything better to do than listen to inflammatory morons like Taitz?

    Even if you repeat a lie time and time again it still remains a lie. Face the facts, Barack Obama is a natural born America citizen.

  13. @Anonymous

    Hey dumbass, there is no such title "natural born American citizen"...

    You can either be a U.S. "Citizen," a "naturalized" citizen, or a "natural born Citizen"...

    Obama may be one of the first two but he is NOT the latter. Unless of course he's lied who his real birth father was.

    The Law of Nations – § 212. Citizens and natives.

    The natives, or natural-born citizens, are those born in the country, of parents who are citizens.

    Statement from the author of the 14th Amendment:

    "I find no fault with the introductory clause [S 61 Bill], which is simply declaratory of what is written in the Constitution, that every human being born within the jurisdiction of the United States of parents not owing allegiance to any foreign sovereignty is, in the language of your Constitution itself, a natural born citizen" -Rep. John Bingham, framer of the 14th Amendment, before The US House of Representatives ((Cong. Globe, 39th, 1st Sess., 1291, March 9, 1866 )

    Attorney Mario Apuzzo: All presidents born after 1787, except for Chester Arthur and Barack Obama, met the “natural born Citizen” criteria.

    P.S., the social security number Obama is presently using, which is confirmed his via the Selective Service website and previous FOIA documents, is a ss# reserved for Connecticut applicants. Obama never lived or worked in that state, EVER!

  14. Always remember this is a double grift. Obama thinks he has outsmarted many but he has been used and his fall will help others. And Obama's mother was very intelligent she worked for Tim Genthers father in banking/espionage. Her mother was adept at records and file manipulation. This literally has been America biggest grift.

  15. @Bob Uda
    The Greatest Fraud has been committed by Obama on the United States. The Government of Kenya has acknowledged that he was born in Kenya and I am a witness to hearing that directly.
    Further, It is no mistake that Obama is President. He is a Terrorist who hates both England and the United States because what happened to his Father in Kenya.
    He has sought from the beginning to destroy the American economy and he is bringing America to it's knees whitout firing a shot.
    It's time to impeach this ScumBag

    JerryBallardUSNRet Tulare, CA

  16. He's a FRAUD, obvious from the day he appointed Tax-Cheat Timmy as head of IRS ! How long will HuffPost and Rachel hold out? Oh, and Jerkhead " Obama's Excuse Man Ed Shultz"

  17. @Anonymous

    If what you say is true, and maybe it is, why does he not produce a birth certificate? The only reason this is an issue is because he wont produce it. That is an issue at all is because he is the first US President of record to have a mothers who's feet barely hit the runway in Hawaii before dumping the kid.
    Its a reasonable question that deserves a reasonable answer...your claims of the writer being a 'moron' aside.

  18. Naco says: Let's impeach this imposter and make him prove that he is a natural born US citizen. Too bad we have so many foreigners in this country telling bonafide Americans what to do. We need to cleanse the US once and for all.

  19. There are criminals serving life sentences in this country who were convicted with less evidence than has been brought against obama.

  20. It isn’t all about the birth certificate. His entire history is a masquerade of deception and obfuscation.

    AKA Obama - We've Got Your Number - 042-68-4425

  21. If it walks like a duck, if it talks like a duck, then facts don't lie. Why is it so hard for people to grasp facts? Obama's henchmen have had two years to try and close the holes of false information. How safe do you feel tonight with the fox guarding the henhouse?

  22. Why did Obama co-sign a bill that requires both parants to be U.S. Citizens? In retaliation against McCain who was born in Panama. Sooo...
    Why is he in the White House? Wake up Amerika!

  23. MSM will never cover this for a fear of a black backlash, yes I know that sounds racist but it is true. Even in 2011 racism exists and people are just too scary to admit it. He will not be touched in court or any other means because he is black, I am black and even I see this!!!

  24. Didn't Hitler's henchman, Goebbels, say something about
    "The bigger the lie, the more it will be believed"???

  25. This Jackass Needs Impeached And Jailed Heehaw Heehaw Heehaw heehaw


“As long as I am an American citizen and American blood runs in these veins I shall hold myself at liberty to speak, to write, and to publish whatever I please on any subject.” - Elijah Parish Lovejoy(1802-1837)

Comments posted here do not necessarily reflect the views of Readers are solely responsible for the content of the comments they post on this web site.